NCC reflection and debate (en)

[edita] Discussions and debate

Clay proposal
theoretical proposal to open up the debate on the authority principle of the author and/or the expert

• Argila (L)
• Discussió:Argila (L)
• Debate forum about Argila-Clay in the OCS congress (read access, closed intervention)

On the limits
of what we call "collective creation "

• Collective creation in the 12/2006 Report
• Cases:
  • Minka y creación colectiva (Minka (L) and collective creation; cooperation Vs. Collective creation)
  • De pidgin a llengua criolla (L) (From pidgin to creole language(L); unconscious creation, in-born mechanisms)
  • És “PoLLECo (L)” creació col·lectiva i/o groupware? (Is “PoLLECo (L)” collective creation and/or groupware?)
  • Pot ser el copyleft una proposta de creació col·lectiva (Is Copyleft a collective creation proposal?)
  • Jam sessions i la creació col·lectiva (Jam sessions and collective creation)
  • Membrana de vianants (pedestrian membrane; unconscious creation, making a phenomenon visible)

Are we all Hackers?
Reflection and fieldwork on active attitudes in technological appropriation

• Tots som hackers!? (We are all hackers!?; Are hacker attitudes as regards to computer science extrapolable to the appropriation of other technologies and objects?)
• Homo habilis; anotacions (Homo habilis; notes; re-interpreting objects as instruments. Are chimps hackers?)
• Hack Quintà (Re-use and creative transformations in the country house workshop)
• Hippel, democratitzant la innovació (Hippel, democratizing innovation; the innovator-user)
• Al taller de Joan Gómez Vinardell (In Joan Gómez Vinardell’s workshop; workshop culture: self-construction, re-use and adaptation)

Other debates

• Discussion: Visibility vs. proposal
• Questions on licenses and authorship

[edita] Concepts

• Net collective creation systems
• Ready-made
• Hack

incorporating concepts

See also: Conceptual Baggage in the July 2006 Report

[edita] Metaphors

Exploring them, questioning them, inventing them, discussing them.

• Metaphors in the December 2006 Report
• Metaphors and concepts in the July 2006 Report
• Metaphor made true: analogic clay - only in Catalan, use Translendium for translation -

[edita] Texts

Project reports and final report

• October 2005: presentation of the project
• July 2006: state of the project and reflections (en)
• Germinador Report - December 2006 (en)

Announcements: congresses and conferences

• FERRER, J & GÓMEZ, D (2006) Germinador de Propuestas de creación colectiva en red (Artech2006) - only spanish, use Translendium for translation -
• FERRER, J & GÓMEZ, D (2006) Argila: un invitació a enfangar-se. Repensar els sistemes de creació col·lectiva en xarxa (Clay: an invitation to becoming waterlogged. Rethinking the systems of net collective creation)(OCS congress; group C-9) - only in Catalan, use Translendium for translation -

Articles

• GÓMEZ, D (2006) Creació col·lectiva: una panoràmica des del projecte Germinador (Collective creation: an outlook from the Germinador project) Papers d'Art (to be puglished in January 2007) - only in Catalan, use Translendium for translation -

Notebook
of comments and reflections in the process

• Versions: diferències entre software i altres obres copyleft
• visibilitat vs. proposta
• Tots som hackers!?
• autoria compartida i creació col·lectiva
• això és una llavor o un germinat?
• debat al voltant de la proposta Argila
• el SouperComputer, llavor o germinat?
• gènesi de la idea "germinador"
• les propostes del Germinador són lliures?
• Veure també: Quadern GERMINADORMaçart

- only in Catalan, use Translendium for translation -
incorporating reflections

[edita] Description and classifications

Tags are used to describe the proposals and this is used to classify them according to their features. The list of traits is open, new tags may be incorporated and the existing can be discussed about.

There is a reference page for the definition and discussion of tags: Tags for proposal traits (en)

Traits of proposals
synchronous - asynchronous - amalgam - mosaic - anonymous - identified user - registered user - partial perception - global perception - onion layers - open - restricted - chain process - tree structure - protocols - comunication resources - decisions - game - surrealist practices - social dimension - common good - software - hardware - non-tech – online - offline - online editing

Proposals according to creation media:
text - graphics - audio - audiovisuals

Models
of systems, abstract proposals and generalizations
Onion layers model - Wiki technologies - copyleft regulations - jam session - collective narration

Schemes
and diagrams, graphic strategies to explain

• Diagram of the process in Chain drawings – Chain gifts
• Illustrated diagrams to compare Clay with the Onion layers model
• Illustrated diagrams of the contributions to the Virgen de las Angustias flower offering
• Diagrams to explain "Vota6" with an interaction scenario

Also, see the list of pages with diagrams.